Can Students Learn to Think, or Are We Still Teaching Them What to Think?
Discover how The School of Raya nurtures critical thinking, helping students evaluate evidence, consider diverse perspectives and form informed conclusions through inquiry and reflection.
Richa Dwivedi
October 20, 2026
0
min read
A student answers a question correctly in class. They remember the concept, explain it well and score high marks in an assessment. But ask them a question they have never encountered before, one that has no clear answer, and the challenge changes.
They have to make sense of what they know, consider different possibilities and decide what they believe. They may even have to question something they were previously certain about.
This is where an important part of education begins.
In a world where information is readily available and answers are only a search away, knowing facts is no longer enough. Students need to learn how to question information, recognise different perspectives, evaluate evidence and form their own conclusions. These abilities take time to develop, and the classroom plays a significant role in shaping them.
The question for educators is worth reflecting on: are we giving students the space to think for themselves?
It begins with the questions we ask
Think about the questions students encounter every day. Some have straightforward answers. Others invite discussion, challenge assumptions and lead to further questions.
Both have their place in learning. The difference lies in whether students are also given opportunities to explore beyond what they have been taught.
In the Primary Years Programme (PYP) at The School of Raya, a student's observation can become the starting point for an inquiry. Something as simple as noticing a change in the environment can lead to questions, investigation and new discoveries. As students progress into the Middle Years Programme (MYP), they are encouraged to examine problems from different perspectives and consider the reasoning behind their responses.
By the time they reach the Diploma Programme (DP), these conversations can become even more complex. In Theory of Knowledge (TOK), students examine how knowledge is formed, what makes evidence convincing and how our experiences influence what we believe to be true.
A discussion that begins with "What do we know?" can lead to a far more challenging question: "How do we know that what we believe is true?"
Questions like these encourage students to look beyond the immediate answer and examine the thinking behind it. They also help students recognise that changing one's mind in the light of new evidence is a strength, not a weakness.
Learning to think takes practice
Critical thinking is often discussed as an essential skill for the future. In practice, it develops through the everyday experiences of learning.
It develops when an experiment produces an unexpected result and students have to work out why. When a mathematical problem can be approached in more than one way. When a discussion introduces a perspective they had not considered. Or when a project does not go as planned and they have to rethink their approach.
Consider a science experiment. If the result differs from what a student expected, the immediate temptation may be to look for the correct answer. But there is value in pausing first. Was an assumption incorrect? Did a variable change? Is there enough evidence to explain the result? What would happen if the experiment were repeated differently?
The same process takes place across other areas of learning.
In the arts, students make choices, interpret ideas and learn to explain what informs their work. In sports, they assess situations, respond to changing conditions and adapt their strategies. During community projects, they may discover that a solution that seemed practical in the classroom does not address the needs of the people involved.
Each experience asks students to draw on what they know and decide how to use it. It also teaches them that mistakes, unexpected outcomes and changing direction are part of the learning process.
These are not always easy lessons. They are, however, valuable ones.
In the arts, students make choices, interpret ideas and learn to explain what informs their work. In sports, they assess situations, respond to changing conditions and adapt their strategies. During community projects, they may discover that a solution that seemed practical in the classroom does not address the needs of the people involved.
Each experience asks students to draw on what they know and decide how to use it. It also teaches them that mistakes, unexpected outcomes and changing direction are part of the learning process.
These are not always easy lessons. They are, however, valuable ones.
Making room for different perspectives
One of the challenges of teaching students to think independently is allowing room for answers that may differ from our own expectations.
When students believe there is only one acceptable response, they can become more concerned with getting the answer right than with understanding the question. They may hesitate to share an idea unless they are certain it will be well received.
A classroom that welcomes discussion creates a different experience. Students can disagree, question an argument and explain why they see an issue differently. They also learn to listen to others and reconsider their own positions when the reasoning or evidence calls for it.
At Raya, TOK discussions offer opportunities for students to engage with questions that do not have easy or universal answers. The conversation becomes as much about the reasoning behind a position as the position itself. Students have to consider what supports a claim, whether the evidence is reliable and how another person might interpret the same information.
Student exhibitions offer a similar opportunity. Whether presenting an inquiry or sharing the outcome of a project, students have to communicate how their thinking developed. What did they set out to discover? Which decisions shaped their work? What changed as they learned more? What would they do differently next time?
These reflections help students become more aware of their own learning. They begin to recognise not only what they have learned, but also how they arrived there.
The role of the educator
Creating this kind of learning environment requires educators to be thoughtful about when to explain, when to guide and when to let students work through a question themselves.
There are times when students need direct instruction and a clear explanation. There are other times when the most useful response is to ask a follow-up question.
"What makes you say that?"
"What evidence supports your view?"
"Could there be another explanation?"
"What might change your mind?"
Such questions encourage students to explain their reasoning rather than simply state a conclusion. They also communicate something important: their ideas are worth examining, and they are capable of doing that examination themselves.
This does not mean leaving students to figure everything out independently. It means providing the right guidance while gradually building their confidence to make decisions, question assumptions and take responsibility for their thinking.
For educators, this also calls for patience. Independent thinking does not develop overnight, and it cannot be measured through a single assessment. It becomes visible over time, in the questions students ask, the connections they make and the way they respond when something challenges what they know.
Preparing students for questions we cannot yet predict
We do not know exactly what the world will look like when today's students enter university, begin their careers or take on leadership roles. New technologies will emerge, established industries will change, and the problems they face may be very different from those we know today.
What will remain important is their ability to make informed decisions, distinguish evidence from assumption, work through uncertainty and consider the consequences of their choices.
At The School of Raya, this is an important part of how we think about learning and the development of our Rayots. Academic knowledge matters, but so does the ability to apply it, question it and connect it to the world beyond the classroom.
We want students to leave school with the confidence to ask questions, the discipline to examine evidence and the judgement to form their own informed perspectives. We want them to be comfortable enough with uncertainty to keep exploring, and open-minded enough to recognise when another perspective has something to teach them.
Perhaps the real measure of learning is not simply whether a student can answer the questions placed before them today, but whether they have developed the curiosity and confidence to engage with the questions that lie ahead.
That is the difference between learning answers and learning to think. And it is a distinction that deserves a place at the heart of education.
Written by
Richa Dwivedi
Head of Marketing
Richa Dwivedi is passionate about building authentic relationships, guiding families with clarity, and sharing stories that bring The School of Raya's vision and culture to life. She has engaged with several families, gaining deep insight into what parents value most in a school's learning environment.
Explore more stories
School of Thought
The School Culture We Build Together
The culture of a school lives in the moments between people, in how we speak, listen, support and respond. A reflection on building a community rooted in respect, empathy, collaboration and care.
Shahnaz
October 13, 2026
•
0
min read
When I think about what makes a school truly good, I do not think only about lessons, results, events, or classrooms. All of these matter, but a school is ultimately shaped by people: how we speak to one another, how we respond when someone needs help, and how we work through challenges together.
I believe there are four essential things that bring out the best in any school community: respect, empathy, collaboration, and follow-through. They sound simple—and perhaps that is the point. The most meaningful values are often simple to understand, but require real intention to practise every day.
Respect is not just a word, idea or rule
Respect should be the foundation of every interaction. Respect is not about agreeing with everyone all the time. Schools are full of different personalities, ideas, concerns, and opinions. Naturally, there will be moments of disagreement. But even in those moments, people should feel that they are being spoken to with dignity.
When adults speak calmly, listen carefully, and avoid making others feel small, students notice. They learn from us—not only from what we teach in class, but from how we treat one another in hallways, meetings, parent conversations, and difficult situations. A respectful school culture tells every person: “You matter here, even when we need to have a difficult conversation.”
Empathy makes guidance meaningful
Empathy is not about avoiding rules or being too soft. It is about pausing before we judge. A student who is quiet may be anxious. A child who is angry may be struggling to express something. A parent who asks many questions may simply need reassurance. A teacher who seems frustrated may need support too.
Instead of asking only, “What went wrong?” we can also ask, “What might this person need right now?”
That small shift can change an entire conversation. It helps us guide people with care rather than assumptions, and it reminds us that every behaviour has a story behind it. Children especially need this. They are still learning how to name emotions, manage conflict, and make sense of the world around them. They need adults who can guide them without making them feel ashamed for struggling.
Collaboration is better than blame
A school works best when no one has to carry a concern alone. Teachers may notice changes in students first. Parents understand their children beyond the school day. Coordinators and leaders help connect people and create systems. Counsellors and wellbeing professionals offer specialised support when needed.
Each role is important, but none should be expected to solve everything alone.
When a challenge arises, the aim should not be to find someone to blame. It should be to understand what happened, identify the support needed, and decide what can be done next. Collaboration turns difficult moments into chances to learn and improve.
Care needs follow-through
Helping during a crisis matters, but what happens after things become calm matters too. A follow-up conversation, a check-in, or a clear plan can help students, families, and teachers feel heard rather than forgotten.
Care is not only about solving a problem quickly. It is about making sure people know they still have support afterwards.
At The School of Raya, the Learner Empowerment Hub aspires to help build this kind of culture: one where students, teachers, and parents can ask for help, receive thoughtful guidance, and feel that their concerns are handled with respect and care.
We may not be at the finish line yet, but we have already begun the journey. With time, openness, and a shared commitment from all of us, I believe we can move closer to the state of flow that we value at Raya—a space where learning, wellbeing, trust, and growth can happen together.
That is the kind of school community I hope we continue to build.
News
Beyond Brochures: Bengaluru Schools Open Doors to Woo Parents
Times of India
October 10, 2026
•
0
min read
The School of Raya is featured in The Times of India for opening its doors to the wider community through events that offer families a glimpse into its learning culture, values and community spirit.
Digging into the Past: MYP 1’s Archaeological Adventure
MYP Year 1 learners stepped into the role of archaeologists, excavating artefacts and uncovering clues about ancient civilisations. Through observation, inference, collaboration and inquiry, they discovered how material evidence can help us reconstruct stories from the past.
Namita Susan Chaly
October 6, 2026
•
0
min read
“Eureka! Look what I found, Miss! It is the Indus Valley Zebu Bull!” exclaimed one excited learner, holding up a newly discovered artefact.
“I’m not able to find the Sphinx, Miss. This is very frustrating, and I’m tired,” shared another learner, visibly worn out after searching for the artefact without success.
These were just two of the many moments that made our MYP 1 archaeological dig site activity memorable. As part of our Individuals & Societies unit, What Can We Learn from Different Civilisations?, learners stepped into the shoes of archaeologists, getting their hands dirty as they excavated, observed, and documented their findings of artefacts from the past.
As their Individuals & Societies facilitators, we paused the activity and invited the learners to reflect on something we often take for granted: the time, patience and effort involved in archaeological discoveries. We spoke about how our knowledge of ancient civilisations has been shaped by archaeologists who painstakingly excavate sites, document their findings and piece together clues left behind by people who lived thousands of years ago. Without their work, our understanding of the past would be far more limited.
The learner who had been frustrated by the elusive Sphinx was suddenly re-energised. With a renewed sense of purpose, they returned to the excavation, ready to try again.
Through this invigorating activity, our MYP 1 learners at The School of Raya explored how we can reconstruct the past when we cannot travel back in time? Rather than beginning with a textbook or a list of historical facts, learners stepped into the role of archaeologists. Working in teams, they explored an excavation site designed to introduce them to the methods used to uncover and study evidence from the past.
Each team worked with a designated excavation area and carefully established a grid using labelled stakes and twine. This introduced learners to the importance of mapping and recording the precise location of archaeological finds. Equipped with soft brushes and small trowels, learners carefully excavated their assigned squares. The excitement of calling out “Eureka!” when an artefact was discovered added to the sense of adventure.
However, the activity was about much more than finding objects. The most meaningful part of the experience came after discovery. Learners were encouraged to move beyond simply identifying an object and begin interpreting what it might reveal.
They considered questions such as:
What does this object suggest about the daily lives of people in the past?
What materials or techniques might have been used to make it?
What can its location tell us?
Which conclusions can we draw from the evidence, and what remains uncertain?
These questions introduced learners to an important distinction in historical inquiry: the difference between an observation and an inference. While an observation describes what we can see, an inference is an interpretation based on the available evidence.
Through the activity, learners developed a foundation for investigating ancient civilisations such as the Indus Valley, Mesopotamia, Egypt and Greece. They began to understand how material remains can provide clues about technology, craftsmanship, trade, settlement patterns and everyday life. An object that might initially appear ordinary could offer valuable insights into the knowledge, creativity and priorities of the society that produced it. A meaningful example is the Code of Hammurabi, an ancient Babylonian law code inscribed on a stone stele. At first glance, it may appear to be just a stone monument covered in writing. However, it reveals that the Babylonians developed a written system of laws to regulate society, resolve disputes and establish punishments for different offences. For instance, the principle of “an eye for an eye” reflects how punishments were linked to the nature of the offence.
The archaeological dig supported the development of several important learning skills. Learners practised research and inquiry by asking focused questions and investigating evidence, while observation and interpretation enabled them to record details accurately and draw evidence-based conclusions. They developed critical thinking by distinguishing between what the artefacts revealed and what they inferred from the evidence. Through teamwork and shared responsibility for the excavation, learners strengthened their collaboration skills. Finally, by documenting their discoveries in field logs and explaining their interpretations clearly, they developed their communication skills
The archaeological dig was a reminder that meaningful learning often begins with curiosity. A grid of soil, a carefully uncovered object and a series of questions became an opportunity for learners to investigate the past using the methods of historians and archaeologists.
After all, every artefact has a story to tell. The challenge is learning how to uncover it.